> there will never be a compiler that can check for bugs in your poem.
Why not? There always were and will be artists who would want to crack their art open, analyze it, understand how it works, and synthesize new art intently, engineering it. And no amount of sacralization of that air of mystery around art will stop that from happening. I’m absolutely sure there will be machines that analyze poetry, model readers/listeners (contemporary or predicted future audiences), and find “bugs” as mismatches between the intended and modeled effects.
And the art won’t be any tiniest bit less enjoyable. Well, unless present-day adtech will survive and abuse it all.
I think it most publicly came for coders, but has been quietly taking over everyone else without them knowing it.
90+% of lawyers, per my lawyer friends, are at risk. High end, safe for a while.
Isn't the legal profession a "protected" one, that is, a practice that requires a certified professional?
Yes, but now each certified professional can handle an order of magnitude more clients. Either the client base grows, or 90% of the attorneys will be out of work.
Worst case scenario: a little bit of both.
Maybe legal representation becomes more affordable, as it should be.
Having been through the civil court process this year, it can absolutely be automated.
Have all parties provide access to bank and email, whatever accounts court wants data from...
AI summarizes it. Judiciary can skip hearings and review.
They don't really take the oral side of things seriously anymore. 100% felt like an empty formality.
Constitutions usually only define Executive, Judiciary, Legislative type roles. The protections you mean are just laws that can change
I think you're missing the purpose of all these processes. They're not there to ensure a fair trail (that could be done far more efficiently), They're there to prove beyond reasonable doubts that the process is fair to all those involved.
This is not a role a black box AI can fill right now. Not because of any missing capability, but because of missing public trust.
I think that's the verbatim copy paste of the philosophy but not tethered to reality
At least in my experience
The case I was a part was very much cut and dry law, based on finances and contracts; no doubts as the digital records were right there
Lawyers in the case just parroted almost verbatim stuff you would hear off Law & Order. Outside court they coached us to feign ignorance. The judges know this as they were lawyers before being judges
Some family court stuff might need human intervention but that should be medical experts and such who submit their findings straight to court.
Lawyers goal is win not "justice". They will manipulate knowledge of available records and evidence to fake reasonable doubt and they don't always get caught.
Laws change all the time.
Taxi driver used to be a "protected" profession.
Yes, and those credentials are literally the only things stopping AI from establishing a beachhead inside their field and advancing.
Law will be fine because the way things are legally set up even if AIs do 100% of the work the lawyer will still have to rubberstamp it. If anything, their lives are gonna get really cushy.
> If anything, their lives are gonna get really cushy.
That is, until someone decides he can do a Ryanair or IKEA on the sector and starts offering law services at 1/5 of the cost for the 90% of the cases where such services are sufficient. Suddenly that new BMW every other year seems to be less of a given.
RocketLawyer's been around since before ChatGPT. Depending on what you need, the comparison to IKEA is apt. Great for generic things that everyone needs/wants; less great for specialized custom stuff. Throw in some AI and it's not clear the timeline.
Doctors too.
not so sure about that. Being a doctor is a physical thing.
Software Engineering is objectively measurable, but needs a different objective measurement (test, benchmark, etc) for each part, feature, behaviour, etc. This is part of why I don't think it's going away as a discipline, although I agree it'll change very significantly.
The areas hit hardest are going to be those where one person can specify the objective once, and then value can be delivered ongoing from that. Data labelling, categorisation, maybe things like QA. Arguably things like autonomous driving.
AI for coders is somewhat analogous to a backhoe or automated welding machine. An operator can do a lot more work than before, but setting it up to do that work correctly and safely still takes skill.
This however will put salary pressure on the people who were simply digging holes or welding beads without being as involved in the planning and design work. Time to remember that we can't forget the business part!
> but setting it up to do that work correctly and safely still takes skill
For now. Not sure why you think that would last though. Obviously the big labs are going to make it easy to use AI both safely and correctly. It's already significantly easier to do that today than a year ago.
> Not sure why you think that would last though.
The failure modes of the LLM are still the same. Nothing has fundamentally changed, despite the UI and the harness showing significant improvements and outcomes.
I completely disagree. The AI tools I've used from the big shops are happy to code visible features, but need real restraint to keep things in order.
I no longer really check the code, but I won't let any of them touch the database schemas. I modify the schema, the machine codes around my database. Same policy with APIs, even private ones.
> but need real restraint to keep things in order.
I second this. Even OpenAI's flagship models... the code I write by hand has much less entropy and is easier to follow than the equivalent AI-generated code. I think part of the software engineering skill now is knowing which pieces you can delegate to AI and which still need human input. I know many people who just YOLO it all and have AI do everything... but, this can hardly make for a stable system in my opinion...
And, I'll be happy to be proven wrong, because it will mean a significant amount of work is off of my shoulders. But I think we aren't quite there yet in terms of having AI code that lowers the complexity instead of raising it in a codebase.
> Time to remember that we can't forget the business part!
There is no reason why AIs wouldn't be able to replace CEOs. It'd be a crime against humanity for us to stop just short of replacing executives.
I don't know how good this poetry major is at coding, but his writing sucks.
So much of what has been automated most of us lament, and so much of what has not been automated we begrudge.
Wut?
The profession so good at their job they automated themselves out of it.
> Yet, as I have said before, there will never be a compiler that can check for bugs in your poem.
I’m quite tired of the code is verifiable bullshit. Of course, it compiles or not, but that’s not the same as did you produce a coherent system, with proper boundaries? Did you decompose the problem properly?
People seem to think that is somehow the easy part. But that is not verifiable at all. Proper abstractions, division of responsibilities etc is not easy and requires non-trivial amounts of knowledge on human psychology.
The clankers are still getting better at it and that stuff isn’t verifiable. Or if it is, pretty damn near everything is. How is law different, finance, etc?
They still aren’t perfect but the fact they are improving on something so intangible should scare the S out of us. Nothing is safe.
> People seem to think that is somehow the easy part. But that is not verifiable at all. Proper abstractions, division of responsibilities etc is not easy and requires non-trivial amounts of knowledge on human psychology.
They seem to believe that these things are not necessary as long as redoing the verifiable aspects is cheap/fast enough.
And yet, there are more coders than ever before.
Yeah, I keep hearing this but my experience is the opposite and more in-line with Jevon's paradox
Jevons paradox would in fact imply that there would be more coders since the demand for coding would have skyrocketed. What do you mean your experience is the opposite? Are there fewer jobs now?
> The paradox is an economic theory stating that technological progress which increases the efficiency of resource use leads to a rise, rather than a fall, in total consumption of that resource
I understood it differently. The paradox doesn't mean more coders any more than Combines necessitated more field workers. More compute, releases and more code changes, yes. I don't believe an increase in demand for developers has manifested as the result of AI tooling becoming widely used.
That the pay of coders could fall so far that it's not a viable way to make a living.
Coding is no longer a viable profession for me. I admit that.
Selling software, however, that's still going strong. I just don't code it anymore. The machine does that.
Yeah, this is a very confusing argument. I don't understand how someone could interpret Jevon's paradox the way they did. It's like saying that more traffic means there are fewer cars on the road.
That doesn't mean what you're implying it means if there's an influx of shovelware generators.
A lot of people are basically using AI as an excuse for their skill obsolesce. It's the same people on HN who would pooh-pooh cloud, JS, k8s, and other skills that are increasingly critical for tech.