Something I don’t quite know, maybe someone closer to math can answer this question
It seems we’re making tremendous progress on the back of existing abstractions and concepts with the brute force ability to generate language and verify proofs.
For example, Tao says about the Riemann proof:
> appears to use the full power of modern developments on the Langlands program and arithmetic geometry
What I wonder: how do we create new abstractions and concepts? Like whatever “Langlands program” is? That then feedback into the system, and allow for even more sophisticated mathematics.
Are we assuming AI will do this? Or does this still need to be something at least agreed-upon by a mathematics community - in the same way programmers talk about a “linked list” without having an hour long conversation to define it axiomatically? And without that social aspect, without breaking down long proofs into Lego block common abstractions, math may plateau? In part because we lose the ability to ask meaningful questions?
This has been ambiguous so far. Most people guessed "the AI can't build new theory yet, but can do insane brute-force, which turns out to be surprisingly powerful, and probably the theory building will get there eventually". I think that in the next 14 days, as this gets processed and understood, there's a good chance we finally settle this.
Compare Elliot Glazer a month-ish ago:
> I occasionally talk to experts on all the MP's. Their rough summaries on what is needed to solve them usually go:
> Hodge: not a clue
> BSD: not a clue
> RH: not a clue
> P vs NP: not a clue
> Yang-Mills: "Well..."
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50252673
So if we're in "not a clue" territory, maybe that's that.
I fear that it gets muddled again with e.g. the concurrent human announcement and that in retrospect RH turns out to be easier than expected, like many other problems before.
Math is hard, but how hard math is is also hard...
> I fear that it gets muddled again with e.g. the concurrent human announcement and that in retrospect RH turns out to be easier than expected, like many other problems before.
The proof in the human announcement is until unverified. I don't expect it to hold water, but to be sure we still have to wait like a month or so to get a few AI assisted analysis. (There are a few pure AI vibe-refutation, but I want to wait until a human checks the AI objections.)
>> the AI can't build new theory yet, but can do insane brute-force, which turns out to be surprisingly powerful, and probably the theory building will get there eventually
A lot of cutting edge math is close to brute-force search, like to throwing stuff to the wall to see what sticks. But at the high level instead of throwing bolts and nuts, you throw BMW and Ferrari.
For example, it's very hard to know how hard a problem is when you already know the solution. It's much easier to verify that the solution is correct than imagining how hard is guessing the tricks to solve it.
Usually after a big proof, parts are reused by the community to prove similar stuff and followups. After a while, the tricks get a name, perhaps lemas are upgraded to theorems, and they may get their own book or course. It's similar to refactoring in programming.
From Andrew Wiles:
> Perhaps I could best describe my experience of doing mathematics in terms of entering a dark mansion. You go into the first room and it's dark, completely dark. You stumble around, bumping into the furniture. Gradually, you learn where each piece of furniture is. And finally, after six months or so, you find the light switch and turn it on. Suddenly, it's all illuminated and you can see exactly where you were. Then you enter the next dark room...
> > Perhaps I could best describe my experience of doing mathematics in terms of entering a dark mansion. You go into the first room and it's dark, completely dark. You stumble around, bumping into the furniture. Gradually, you learn where each piece of furniture is. And finally, after six months or so, you find the light switch and turn it on. Suddenly, it's all illuminated and you can see exactly where you were. Then you enter the next dark room...
I feel this is a great analogy except for the part about the light switch. It feels much more like the stumbling around the dark and then understanding where everything is until you know it perfectly and don't need the light switch any more. The level of mathematics currently is so incredibly complex that "a light switch" would seem to indicate "anyone can see or understand it" but that's so far from the truth.
It's really more stumbling around in the dark until you don't need a light. And it becomes easier for others to build off because you leave behind a map that they can use and therefore they don't need to do the stumbling.
I think the light switch represents the Aha moment where things come together in a hyper way. And it also represents the fact that these rooms don’t have to be dark. We just don’t understand them. Some other intelligent life may walk in and say “the light switch is usually right here”.
CAVEMAN SUMMARY: AI no need theory, only people need. Fable understand OpenAI math. Fable explain well to human. People the problem, not AI.
I was reading a mathematician's take on a recent OpenAI proof (their area of expertise). They argued that models don't lack theory building, they just work at such a high level of abstraction that they don't need it.
Theory is for us, so we can understand what the models are doing. They gave the example of Fable, which understood and explained everything perfectly right away (written by OpenAI's unreleased model in terse mathematical notiations).
This was totally intuitive for the AI (Fable), but it took this person two weeks just to get a high-level grasp of it. And this person is one of the few people on earth who can (he is an expert in this niche of mathematics).
I imagine more semantically comprehensible proofs benefit LLMs as much as they benefit humans, from a time/energy/iq perspective.
Ergo, there are likely numerous deeper insights that will emerge when smarter models have the chance to go over brute forced, millions of line Lean proofs. Likely things humans have not conceived, but I believe will truly advance understanding. Post-train the existing models with that knowledge, and see them resolve these same problems with far less effort.
Just a hunch. I'm neither an AI researcher nor a mathematician.
Reminds me of the Bicameral Order from Blindsight / Echopraxia books by David Brin, where you had post-humans operating on such a different level of intelligence that you needed a translation layer between them and the rest of humanity just for "regular" humans to have a chance at comprehending even a little of the mathematical and scientific discoveries they were making.
Just for the benefit of others, are you referring to this?
https://web.maths.unsw.edu.au/~davidharvey/research/subnlogn...
Yes! Thank you for linking it here. I couldn't find it for the life of me.
The conclusion you drew from that article is the opposite of what the article claimed, though. Check my comment here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50592554
Humans experience reality, and as they do so they gradually build maps—models—that allow them to reason about it with less overhead. Those maps are hopefully useful for some purpose, but also necessarily wrong/incomplete.
LLMs only operate on our pre-existing maps in their training dataset. (The first “L” is the key: language is itself a map.) They may be useful at refining those models, but they do not experience and therefore cannot get us to the next peak over.
I love how you wrote these half assed ambiguous/incoherent theories right under a thread where ai's made some of the most immense mathematical developments in perhaps a century.
I chalk up your rude and dismissive reply to AI psychosis. These achievements you mention are vastly overblown, and they are not at all "immense mathematical developments". There's a saying among mathematicians: "Good mathematicians prove theorems, great mathematicians make conjunctures, the greatest mathematicians write definitions (aka build theories)". This is what GP was gesturing at, and it's completely accurate. AI doesn't build theories, regardless of GGP's paraphrased quote, which was incorrect: in fact the mathematician was saying just the opposite. See my comment here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50592554
It just so happens that in the past minds that were able to crack difficult problems happened to also be the ones who could advance mathematics by breaking new ground and posing new and fertile questions. Same as how before the invention of the calculator, people who could calculate pi to the nth decimal were also people who also had other math skills calculators never could touch.
It's not incoherent. It's describing an abstraction ladder.
It's how you graduate from 1+1+1 to 3*1. And so on.
Certainly, I am fully in support of more forms of data being added as the native mode of thought. Visual and tactile and audio based data would be necessary next step for physical robots.
> I love how you wrote these half assed ambiguous theories right under a thread where ai's made some of the most immense mathematical developments in perhaps a century.
Rest assured, not nearly as much as I love how someone on such a respected forum runs out of arguments in their first reply to me.
Because you made up incoherent undefined nonsense, and in your previous argument chain literally had to ignore reality to salavge your points. You would have had to define what you mean by experience and explain why sense organs that accept text are not sense organs while sense organs that experience visual and force and audio data are senses. Modela are multimodal in any case these days. And yes I am certainly rooting for ai to debe developed that also traina in visual, audio and force data natively along with language. Wouls be fun to see the next wave of copes and excuses aftet that.
s/rooting for ai to debe developed that also traina/rooting for ai to be developed thats also trained
That's an incorrect interpretation of what that mathematician said, which was in fact the opposite: the models have such power of computation that they can just brute-force a problem without needing to climb a ladder of abstraction. Which explains why the Lean proof to the GRH is 200k page and about 17 million lines long.
Here's an in-depth explanation from Gemini Neon: https://share.gemini.google/lPWabl6Goaxc
The question is, do the models actually understand what they are doing? I would say no, though they can be used to understand the proof later. They are just blindly tunneling through the state space and brute-forcing their way to the solution. With some very unwanted side-effects on the environment to boot.
This is weird, so you think letting agent loose with "solve cancer, and giving them unlimited compute, with no further guidance, will yield results??
People seems to have lost their sense of judgment. It was the same with Deep Blue and AlphaX, the world's problem did not end. If we are to make progress in many field, it is still people who will have to build new theories, etc.
> This was totally intuitive for the AI (Fable)
I'm regularly getting replies from a Fable-related model about our code base and problem space which would suggest that it totally inuitively groks it when it confidently explains and asserts things, and more often than I'd like it turns out that it's wrong, the thing is actually different and/or more complicated than what it made it out to be, and when I point that out it apologizes and agrees with me, rinse and repeat.
I'd be very careful with such claims. LLMs have been around for long enough for us to still fall for its confidence.
Then It's just a case of unambiguously defining the question, and getting the model to explain the answer.
I swear, if it says 42, I'll be laughing.
I thought theory building WAS the process of creating powerful abstractions?
Open question - are these proofs brute forcing, or are they generating new theory at a level of abstraction and complexity we can't understand?
Controversial statement: I think we've always done math by generalising from concrete experience. So concepts like numbers, spaces, shapes, distances, and curvature are based on physical experiences we use as anchors before expanding them far beyond physicality and looking for patterns in the abstractions.
If AI is generalising from patterns in latent space, that's a different kind of abstraction, and one that's much more alien to us, because it's going to be much, much bigger - too big to fit inside even the smartest human mind.
So AI theories and abstractions may be valid in true/false terms, but we will never be able to comprehend them in their raw form - just as we can't experience latent space directly, and will only experience tiny slices of it as outputs to our queries.
> If AI is generalising from patterns in latent space, that's a different kind of abstraction
How's latent space conceptually different from neuronal activations in our brains?
> just as we can't experience latent space directly,
Your LLM also doesn't "experience" their activations in the latent space either when generating tokens.
I'm not saying LLMs are not conscious/sentient/etc. Just saying if you ask your LLM which activation was stronger that led to a particular solution, they won't be able to answer without using external tools to inspect it.
It may just be that LLMs have such a huge context window (short-term memory) compared to humans, that they can process a lot more raw data without having to compress them into theories yet.
Human short-term memory and LLM context windows are very different things.
More generally, your mental model of how the human brain works seems to be very much aligned with how LLMs work and I would very much caution against that.
I think most won't be understood in 14 days; but ofc ai can make theory now
The recent progress in AI maths I think has made it a lot more obvious and visible what maths is at its core: The study of interesting patterns that emerge from the consistent application of simple rules.
It's quite similar to the Game of Life and the community around it that tries to find interesting ever fancier gliders in that way.
The thing about maths though is that what counts as big and interesting is socially determined and chosen by the community over decades or centuries.
It remains to be seen whether human mathematicians will be content with also having the AI decide what's interesting.
One possibility I suppose is to find an objective definition of what's interesting, e.g. some sort of centrality score to a theorem within the tree of theorems it enables.
> find an objective definition of what's interesting
Say that any louder and the lecture hall will be lousy with economists!
Straight from the armchair: We might say the techniques of this Riemann proof rest heavy on existing abstractions; even granting that, the reasoning near the result is so important that your default assumption should be that the result itself is significant and useful new abstraction.
I understand the "tunneling straight to the problem instead of building a coherent path" analogy, but even granting that is completely accurate (and not overstated one bit), then at the very least we can use AI not to keep tunneling, but to digest this proof and re-connect it to that "coherent [human understandable] path."
Right now the focus of the mathematicians is understandably to 'mine' solutions as fast as they can. At some point famous problems will run out and proving arbitrary problems will not be so exciting. But there is rich and fertile ground in refining proofs.
For instance: humans might be much more excited if a proof of Fermat that actually did fit in the margin of an old book was found than a 1.5 million line Lean proof of Riemann.
A lot of people have raised the possibility of math may plateau because humans no longer have the insights for new abstractions, but the truth is nobody knows.
Langlands is interesting because it is most conjectural (and not completely clear what the precise statements are -- hence "program" and not "conjecture"), but proving special cases turn out to be tremendously powerful. One special case implied Fermat's Last Theorem, for example.
Maybe they'll do what I do with programming: tell it to suggest new abstractions I can use. I tell the computer all the time to think of ways to create new classes or refactor the codebase in a way that makes more sense.
If you ask for abstractions to use in your code you don’t get anything remotely “new”. I do it but I get well known, proven ideas (which is great)
The Langlands program is as old as 1967, it translates hard problems in number theory (like primes and polynomials) into problems in geometry and harmonic analysis (like symmetries and waves), where we have other tools to solve them.
The Langlands program just makes sense. The best most succinct definition of the set of real numbers can be put as "a complete ordered field." We usually experience them as decimals and infinitesimals, etc but when you think about them in the context of those three meaningful, powerful words you realize harmonics and geometry make so much sense. And also how primes etc are connected to quantum
Chat is this woo?
No. It's about connecting two areas/domains of mathematics.
An example would be how you can specify complex numbers in multiple forms:
- as a (real, imaginary) pair using the definitions of operations like addition and multiplication;
- as a 2x2 matrix, with 1 and i having matrix representations;
- as a 2D vector (angle, magnitude).
The idea is that if you prove something in one area you can apply that proof to the other domain using the equivalence mappings without having to prove all of those in the target domain. The basic construction is:
- have the problem in domain A (e.g. a complex number in (re, im) form);
- apply mappings converting domain A to domain B (e.g. representing the complex number as a 2x2 matrix);
- apply the proof from domain B;
- apply mappings converting domain B to domain A;
- QED
In a way, the Langlands program is like a subset of Concept Theory.
Given what we've seen, I see no reason to think that AI couldn't produce meaningful abstractions like perfectoid spaces or rough paths, and even give them memorable names. The pertinent issue to me seems to be the opposite of your concern. Right now, a scenario of 'runaway math' seems conceivable, where machines produce ever more complex results about ever more complex abstractions. At a rate exceeding the capacity of the human mathematical community to comprehend (the capacity limit might also be just physical - even if every single result could still be understood by humans, there might not be enough humans who care with enough time to go through all of it). The more real constraint seems to be economical, as in who would dedicate the hardware and energy to producing the math, and why would they make the results public.
In this case, deepening our math knowledge becomes an empirical process like a physical science. We have reams and reams of 'truth' in the physical universe, but nobody knows what its or how it connects to our current understanding. Now, mathematicians exist to empirically probe and test their assumptions against this massive 'physical' edifice of endless proven, interconnected maths like trying to understand the chemistry of a human cell.
It's there, we can observe it, but we still need to study it / take it apart to be able to explain it.
even the basics of LLM, we dont have full understanding of math behind LLM.
would be a great idea for mathematicians to build the "Standard Model" of AI/LLM from mathematics perspective. Currently its resembles alchemy and brute-force more than anything
100% what a great reply!
It's highly probable that each AI proof will basically produce its own abstractions, since it doesn't need to establish a "research program" that should be "understood" by the "community".
Maybe we'll use AI to read through all these AI proofs and write them in a common language as "lectures" for the 3-4 people who will still be "interested" in learning new "math" (I count myself among them).
(Sorry for the abundance of scare quotes.)
> It's highly probable that each AI proof will basically produce its own abstractions
I am not looking forward to the further silo-nation of math, where even the abstractions live only in one small area.
I think your later comment clarifies that you see this as a negative.
We build abstractions to transport understanding across fields. It is plausible to me that in some huge proofs (like FLT), there could be a role for proof-specific abstractions. In general, though, a lack of abstractions that cross boundaries makes me think the abstractions are not sufficiently powerful/useful.
What? Virtually everyone who writes a math paper "produces abstractions" in the course of doing so. It's a more routine and mundane activity than perhaps you are imagining.
The scare quotes are indeed doing a lot of work here -- for instance, I read the ones wrapping "community" as implying there won't be a mathematics community that will need to understand new research, which is a fairly bold claim deserving some justification.
You should try being a bit more explicit in general. Particularly so, given that this is a domain and community that you don't seem especially familiar with. By that I mean "be explicit about what you mean, clarify your analogies -- better yet, avoid them until you understand the topic deeply -- and define important terms"
> It's a more routine and mundane activity than perhaps you are imagining.
I know. I am a mathematician. I mean that the abstractions will only be done in this mundane way. (I produced some myself.)
Exactly like in commercial work - dark forest, where swarms of hungry AI equipped copycats are swarming to steal and exploit any original idea anyone has, thus demotivating anyone from coming with ideas.
I feel it is the same in computer security, it will be interesting to observe for both, if among the proofs remaining to make or new, if a human could make them whereas models weren't able to do so, and in sec what new bugs are found that models couldn't. Also it would be interesting to see if new classes of proofs or bugs resist, despite their attempted learning to the models once known. Could something resist to their learning? Is there something human could durably do that models or future models can't?
That's kinda the big question right now.
Today, humans are left to create the theories, even as AI becomes super-human at proof solving. No one can say how long that equilibrium will last.
Nobody knows the answer to that question, we are discovering in real-time what frontier mathematicians and frontier AI are able to do to solve previously unsolved problems.
That being said, its probably going something akin to how experimental and theoretical physics have an interplay with each other.
Can we develop more and more all encompassing abstractions (theories) that explain and verify experimental results; translates to, can we come up with more and more theorems/abstractions that explain formal proofs (and perhaps provide explanations for other known proofs)? Probably yes, and likely will also be accelerated by AI.
How this fits into the discipline of mathematics is something we are currently finding out.
It reminds me of the old movie "Pi" (a good movie). A crazy mathematician finds a new transcendental number and people are chasing him to try to get it because it's so powerful.
He tells them "I could give it you, but you wouldn't know what to do with it."
A new proof doesn't really do anything on its own if we don't know how to make use of it. It's like handing a set of Vernier Calipers to a Chimpanzee. The growth and innovation from developing the proof is where the real value is.
Langlands program[0] was proposed by the Canadian mathematician Robert Langlands (1967, 1970) seeking to relate the structure of Galois groups in algebraic number theory to automorphic forms and, more generally...
cutting that quote immediately before "representation theory" is very funny in a matmul-heavy zeitgeist; representation theory is representing algebraic structures as matrices where you can bring more familiar tools to bear.
> What I wonder: how do we create new abstractions and concepts?
By keeping mathematicians on the payroll and letting them do their jobs. It's always been their primary objective and it will continue to be.
> Are we assuming AI will do this?
It can't because it is fundamentally about asking questions about what we as humans find interesting.The machine can't know that. It could suggest questions and it can help answering them. But what is "interesting" is fundamentally subjective.
> What I wonder: how do we create new abstractions and concepts?
Mathematicians are already afraind they might not undestand all of the applications of existing concepts. When completely novel things without names start poping up they will be completely freaked out, like go players over the move 37.
My take on this is that new abstractions and concepts are sort of efficiencies you may use to tackle a problem. The more abstractions you have, the less energy you need to come up with a proof. So its like a spectrum.
One of the things I wanted to understand or simulate was, can we remove some abstractions and concepts and come up with a proof of some conjecture like Fermat's Last Theorem? I assume this proof involved a lot of modern abstractions. But if we can ask Claude to use only rudimentary concepts that a high school kid knows, could we come up with a proof that, while possibly huge, is correct?
LLMs are great at ‘seems’. the big question is, is it real? I’m automatically suspicious when the proof is 250k pages long.
Put these new proofs that are being made into the dataset for training the next model. Just use the bitter lesson and increase the amount of proof data.
Of Outsourcing the brute forcing the parts one struggles at leaves more space for exploring what’s left.
> Of Outsourcing the brute forcing the parts one struggles at leaves more space for exploring what’s left.
Except the tasks are probably not so neatly divided.
* Exploration and insight might be a side effect of a human doing "brute forcing."
* AI may vacuum up all the intermediate successes and quick wins that keep people motivated, making it practically impossible for a person to "create new abstractions and concepts" at the frontier.
* etc.
>Are we assuming AI will do this?
Yes.
So what is a greater accomplishment, formulating the hypothesis, or coming up with the proof?
I think the proof.
Although I assume in the future AI will be doing all of it, and humans are going to be less and less capable of comprehending the outcome.
Re: geometry and 6-Channel Dual Schubert QFIM and Sato Grassmanian Gr_p(H) and Polarized Hilbert space; "5. Li’s Unit-Circle Criterion and Why Finite Zero Audits Do Not Close Classical RH" https://westurner.github.io/sustainablefactory/grassmannian-...
And from the unifications paper from this series of papers, working title "Turner Grassmanian Series: Mutant League Physics; The Caret Wedge" or "Unification, Engineering Applications, and Research Roadmap of Complex Grassmannian \(Gr_{\mathbb{C}}(2,4)\), \(Gr_{\mathbb{C}}(2,6)\), and Dilatant Dark Fluid (DDF) Mechanics: Cross-Domain Plücker Invariants, Photonic–Thermal–Quantum Systems, and Formal Verification in Lean 4 — Sustainable Factory 0.1.0 documentation https://westurner.github.io/sustainablefactory/grassmannian-...
> 2.13 Infinite-Dimensional Sato–Segal–Wilson Hilbert-Space Grassmannian Gr_res(H) , Integrable PDE Solvers (KP-II / KdV / Boussinesq / AKNS), Dual-Schubert QFIM, Adelic Carleman–Weierstrass det3 , & Spectral RH Gap Audit (Papers 51 & 52) (Signals.SatoGrassmannian [21 modules], Signals.Pending.SatoRiemannSpectralPendingBoundary, sato_grassmannian.rs, sustainablefactory/sato_grassmannian.py)
> 2.14 Compressible & Incompressible Navier–Stokes via Three-Channel Plücker–Madelung & Six-Channel Dual-Schubert QFIM (Paper 53) (Signals.NavierStokes [PluckerFrame, Incompressible, Compressible], Signals.Pending.DualSchubertNavierStokesPendingBoundary, navier_stokes.rs, sustainablefactory/navier_stokes.py)
I just put all of this on compressible and incompressible NS together today but have been working on those for a few months with a few hundred dollars of tokens. I haven't yet looked at their 17M Langlands program solution; hopefully there's some insight there.
We had the first 30 zeros with our numerical implementation before we found Toupin's 2025 manuscript On the Nature of Nature: Celestial Holography to the Zeta Zeros this week on gscholar looking for geometry and proof of Hilbert-Polya, but at least four gaps remain in the RH Lean and IDK how much time I'll have for this given the free KdV/KP-II solver for doing the Sato Grassmanian to Hilbert work.
"Adelic Carleman–Weierstrass Regularized Determinants (det2,det3 ), Schwinger 2-Cocycle Central Extensions, Segal–Wilson Determinant Bundles, 1(ℝ) Weil Positivity, and Formal Bridges to Signals.RiemannSpectral in Lean 4, Rust/PyO3, and mpmath" > 7. Open Boundaries Recorded in Signals.Pending.SatoRiemannSpectralPendingBoundary https://westurner.github.io/sustainablefactory/grassmannian-...
https://leanprover.zulipchat.com/#narrow/channel/113488-gene...
It looks like two independent kernels accept the result, which means its likely that there are no kernel bug exploitations in the proof.
Back in July the invalid proof of false for the Collatz conjecture also checked in two independent kernels (i.e. the official one and nanoda)
At least as I understood it, this was effectively two bug reports - one against lean another against nanoda - linked by a proof wittily engineered to pass both.
Is anyone else struggling with feelings of both excitement and terror? I haven't felt this much personal uncertainty about my career/life since I was an L1 MLE (10 years ago).
I've been programming since I was 12 and working in the industry for 13 years, and honestly I think I'm done with it all.
I'm starting studies to be an electrician course next year. I want to work in an industry where I'm expected to do high quality work, made to last decades. I want to be as far away as possible from the slopfest.
My stepfather is an electrician, just about 30 years in the trade.
If you are looking to escape the "slopfest" and to do high quality work made to last decades, you are in for a rude awakening. For most of my life, I was subjected to overhearing frantic and frustrated phonecalls where my stepfather had to deal with shoddy work, lazy coworkers, and general bad behavior. This was true when he was a journeyman and when he was a master, foreman or not.
I used to think it was a feature of that line of work, but when I started working in software I just realized it was the nature of any "builder" role; you the four axes of people who care, people who don't care, people who want to get shit done, and people who just want to get paid. You and your colleagues are all going to chart and then be thrown against projects that demand some bar of execution on some timeline, with all the lovely conflict and shortcuts that implies.
It doesn't have to be that way. Everyone has had a bad story in any field, but if you're really smart, you can probably make a go of it being an electrician and I think the probability of having a happy life there is much better than programming, which in my view is a guaranteed soul-crusher if you dislike what AI is doing to it. At least with electrician, you have a chance.
He’s literally saying does have to be that way because in his opinion it is human behavior.
If something is the way it is, and nothing seems to change it, then how can you prove it doesn't "have" to be that way?
Maybe it does. Things are the way they are for a reason.
You've not identified with OPs uncertainty - you've become certain on a cynical outcome.
If AI continues at this rate there's no point in being classically "useful" in the utilitarian sense.
The thing to do is see what you're good at, be it playing guitar or whatever, and just go and do that as well as possible among real humans.
>The thing to do is see what you're good at, be it playing guitar or whatever, and just go and do that as well as possible among real humans.
Cool. But in a world where nothing humans do has any market value how does one actually... earn a living?
Because let's be clear, the post-scarcity work free Star Trek utopia that people think AI will create isn't happening. UBI isn't happening. They will literally gun us down and roll us into mass graves with bulldozers before they allow any of us to opt out of capitalism.
It's not worth you worrying about. Most people will have no influence on the outcome.
You might as well do something you're good at and enjoy with people that you enjoy the company of, which curiously enough is what other people would find most valuable about you in those situations.
> It's not worth you worrying about. Most people will have no influence on the outcome.
Knowing the route an invading army will come can make the difference between a good life and a grisly death.
People worry for themselves and their families. Even if one person cannot influence a global trend, the right planning (or guess) could leave them prosperous (enough).
This is an absolutely insane take. You should be ashamed of thinking this way.
It is worth worrying about. I would love nothing more than to spend the rest of my life writing short stories and cranking out games for my own pleasure and maybe other people's enjoyment but I also need to eat.
"kumbaya my lord..." [death bulldozer advances] "kumbaya"
> But in a world where nothing humans do has any market value
Computers surpassed humans in chess decades ago and there are more humans making money with chess now than there were back then.
Well but chess is a sport where the "business" value is not in the work itself. This doesn't transfer to traditional "work".
What does any of that have to do with opting out of capitalism?
UBI is entirely consistent with capitalism.
You have to stop the progress of enshittification, to have UBI keep up with the "cost of living crisis" that the former causes.
UBI works... So long as the industries around it aren't doing their best to force it to fail. If the politicians responsible for deploying it, aren't best friends with those looking to undercut it.
Income not earned through labor under market conditions is by definition not consistent with capitalism. UBI would be a socialist program. All welfare programs are socialist.
In most countries (in the West at least, afaik):
- there has been some form of labor market, i.e. at least some people are able to earn income through labor under market conditions - that is capitalism per your definition
- there has been some form of welfare programs, even if limited (e.g. almshouse) - that is socialism, per your definition
since basically time immemorial.
If pretty much all places at pretty much all times were capitalist-socialist - from the East India company to medieval fairs to WWII Germany - then there is not much point in using those terms, no? They don't bring any more information than saying "the economy is a thing".
I think it is pointless to use those terms as absolutes, to imply that an economy must be either entirely capitalist or entirely socialist. Reality is more complex and messy than that. Modern China is more capitalist than the US in some ways.
What about the modern crop of tech companies gives you any faith that they’d willingly pay taxes to any jurisdiction instead of just lobbying their friends in power and hoarding their wealth? They don’t want to pay the lowest tax rates in modern history and they’re certainly not going to willingly pay higher rates than that which would be necessary for anything UBI
> They will literally gun us down and roll us into mass graves with bulldozers before they allow any of us to opt out of capitalism.
To quote a recent Amon Amarth song: "Everyone must die, so die with a war cry." If it actually comes to that and there's nothing left to lose, we might as well go out with a bang.
Any major increase in desperation and hopelessness is going to lead to violence and crime. It doesn't matter if it's caused by AI, or climate change, or exploitation. We're all better off when the people around us have something to live for and feel like they can meaningfully improve their condition.
That is why I don't think dystopian fantasies about the evil rich and bad capitalism are likely to manifest in the future.
Even if I were to accept the premise that most of the rich are selfish psychopaths with zero empathy, there is an obvious benefit to providing welfare.
When productivity surges to let's say triple the output, why not give a third away as a welfare distribution, and have everyone live a comfortable and peaceful life?
That welfare may not look like what you'd expect. History is filled with slaves and peasants abused by rich people. Even today you can hear people envious of their slave owner ancestors argue that the slaves were "treated well" and "given jobs" and a "better lifestyle than they would have had" so it was all fine. It doesn't always last for very long but it can last long enough for several generations of a small few to live and die with every available comfort while exploiting masses of people.
On a long enough timeline it's bound to fall apart, but the more resources you have the longer you can keep the game up. Right now the psychopaths with zero empathy have underground bunker-palaces, mass-surveillance, and robot dogs with flamethrowers so they're feeling pretty bold. They dream of AI removing the need to keep so many of the peasant class alive and while I doubt LLMs will do that for them, if they pull that off they can keep our numbers low enough to be manageable for even longer.
Would it be better for them to make sure that people are happy and thriving? Probably, but pathological greed and a bet that they'll die before things get bad enough for them are the problem. You see it already in climate change. They've got zero issues poisoning the air and water and accelerating the mass extinction event already underway because they know they're rich enough that it won't impact them too much in their own lifetime. They don't even care about their future grandchildren/great-grandchildren because "fuck you, I got mine" is kind of their whole thing.
"One day our masters will surely be overthrown" isn't much comfort when you, your kids, and your parents, and their parents have all been enslaved.
I'd focus a bit more on the argument of why the rich wouldn't spend a third on welfare - they already pay taxes today. I think it would make for more interesting discussion than going on about slavery.
Vaguely pointing at pathological greed hasn't convinced me, and the climate change comparison falls short. You would need to extend that to the majority of the population since few care to sacrifice any personal convenience for climate action. You also vastly overestimate the impact of climate change on our grandchildren, which will almost certainly be negligible.
> they already pay taxes today.
They do everything in their power to avoid doing that and do it only because failure to risks jail time. They've bribed enough lawmakers and written enough of the tax code to leave them a lot of room for shenanigans, but straying too far outside of that is one of the few crimes that even the ultra-wealthy have to worry about being busted for.
> You would need to extend that to the majority of the population since few care to sacrifice any personal convenience for climate action.
There is no action the majority of the population can take that will hold a candle to the very small number of people doing the overwhelming amount of harm. Optimistically, I'd suggest that voting might come close, provided the people they vote for enact what would certainly be seen as radical policy changes.
> You also vastly overestimate the impact of climate change on our grandchildren, which will almost certainly be negligible.
It isn't negligible for our children today. It's not impacting the children of the ultra-wealthy, but for "the poors" it's already displacing families, driving famine (https://time.com/6081919/famine-climate-change-madagascar/), and killing millions every year (https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-07-07/climate-c...).
While much of the worst current impacts are hitting poors elsewhere, deaths are happening here in the US too, although it's very difficult to put a specific number on them https://www.npr.org/2024/06/10/nx-s1-4842299/climate-disaste....
People in the US are seeing the impacts in other ways too, like those whose homes are now uninsurable or facing huge spikes in insurance costs. https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20240311-why-climate-chan...
> Right now the psychopaths with zero empathy have underground bunker-palaces, mass-surveillance, and robot dogs with flamethrowers so they're feeling pretty bold. They dream of AI removing the need to keep so many of the peasant class alive
Who are you talking about? Any specific names?
Billionaires without exception. Oligarchs, CEOs. This is obvious to anyone who isn't striving to join the oppressive capitalist oligarch class.
Some of it may have involved just a small touch of hyperbole and speculation. I don't actually know anyone who owns a robot dog with a flamethrower. They do exist though https://throwflame.com/products/thermonator-robodog/
Are you kidding? People less fortunate than you are living that dystopian reality today.
Just go live the amish way, but with another cut date. Like year 2020.
The Amish can live the way they do because they exist in a community where people help each other overcome the challenges with that way of living, and that community is held together by shared religious belief that makes such sticking together a serious matter of either salvation or damnation. People out in the secular world wanting to opt out of change at an arbitrary cut date probably won't have that community around them to make it feasible.
> Because let's be clear, the post-scarcity work free Star Trek utopia that people think AI will create isn't happening. UBI isn't happening.
I hate this kind of pseudointellectual demoralization. You cannot know that for sure. No one can know today what will happen.
Never give up prematurely.
Precedent is clear and unyielding; when have the monied class ever willing shared the bounty of productivity gains the past decades? Never. The only reason Musk/Dario/Altman espouse ubi is because they won’t be paying for it, their customers will via taxes on agents (so they desire).
The only good thing is that most tasks in the economy are not as amenable to ai as coding is. It’ll take years to adopt through out the economy just as electrification did.
>I hate this kind of pseudointellectual demoralization.
Nothing of the sort, simply an awareness of what capitalism is and what capitalists are willing to do to preserve their power. And that AI is a capitalist project run by a cult of neo-fascist accelerationists. Keep the sunshine and rainbows in your heart if you need to, though. I think it's pretty clear what a world created in the image of Thiel, Andreessen and Musk and that ilk will lead to.
I expect the worst because nothing I've seen over the last decade leads me to believe humanity is capable of better.
To quote Ursula Le Guin:
“ We live in capitalism. Its power seems inescapable. So did the divine right of kings. Any human power can be resisted and changed by human beings. Resistance and change often begin in art, and very often in our art, the art of words.”
There is no point for millions to become guitar players (I know, quite a few options but then there are billions of us and this one would be among most popular choices). At least no point if earning sustainable wage in such society is the goal.
It may happen as you describe, it may not. I don't think it will take a decade, maybe 3, still waiting for those fully self driving cars where I can sit back and sleep or read, they are just around the corner for past 10+ years. Software and white collar work is one thing to replace, but 0 error tolerance of many real world jobs will have to come up with something fundamentally different, or extremely well tested.
I've done few full reconstructions with very skilled workers and let me tell you those guys will retire just fine. Their work even in 2026 is often very custom to specific situations and has to be darn creative where tons of experience is essential, guidelines are pretty broad and focus mostly on safety. Electrician, plumber, tiling specialist, all of them knew the other's parts well enough, plus other required jobs they witnessed and sometimes participated daily for decades. Together they could do any interior job, know all the tools, processes, materials etc. Most of their work are interior renovations, new buildings are not that common in many parts of Europe (good land already built on, building material rose significantly during covid and mostly didn't come back etc). Personal connection helped see a bit behind curtain of the business and get work done on higher level when I made clear there are no hard deadlines, and I focus on quality.
Probably the most safely employed guys I know as we speak, but their health is variously wrecked, its tough job and various chemical crap they are daily exposed to would make common HNer weep and run for truckload of carbon filters.
Sure. But who hires or generates most of the need for all the electrician, plumber, tiling specialists and so on...? Well-paid white collars. And if that category of people disappears...
>Probably the most safely employed guys I know as we speak
Ah yes, "physical workers". Surely nothing will perturb their work opportunities, as the long-renowned class of book writers, programmers, mathematicians also see no change in their lives, or God forbid, become completely dispensable.
Haha, why would that ever come to be.
Why do we need custom houses. Only the rich will have them.
Instead we could have some AI-designed and robot manufactured communist block apartments to house our carcasses until the end.
This is such a weird sentiment to be making. Imagine if we have finally made food free to make, we can make any kind of food from a slop factory by mixing insects and leaves. It works! It contain the nutrients that we expect from genuine dairies.
Is this such a bad idea? We will live in an era of food abundance across the globe.
As it stands now, Sillicon Valley is absorbing a lot of talents from across the world. No one in my country can compensate a good enough person from just going to Singapore or US. So what if software engineering is now just another job? No more 500k compensation on your first year doing who knows what in Google.
If water desalination is free, I wouldn't be crying for Dasani because they can't sell bottled water anymore.
have you not seen the humanoid robots sorting parts in the bmw factory 24/7? AI coming for physical labor too
Automation in a factory? How unprecedented!
In the coming years, should we survive, you will be surprised at how fast robotics progresses. You will likely spend years training for a profession which will be quickly stripped from you.
Please do what makes you happy, but the right calculation I believe is to spend time with those you love, and do what you need to do to live an okay life in the meantime, but no more.
I say this not to be negative, or a doomer, I just I worry you will regret your decision when another career is taken from you, or when you realise you wasted time planning for a future that will never come.
I think this is correct advice.
No one can predict the future and what the labor market will be like by 2030. Training for a new profession now does not seem worth it unless it makes you happy.
Taking some time off now could make sense, and then see in a year or two what the situation looks like.
Staying in the current software engineering job also seems like a good idea when someone is still being paid handsomely and the work is easier than ever right now with the AI assistance.
I wouldn't advise doing what makes you happy in the short term any more. I'd advise instead to make enough money to survive happily in a developing country, get a tiny house there, and just avoid society.
>I want to work in an industry where I'm expected to do high quality work, made to last decades.
>I'm starting studies to be an electrician
Oh man I have some bad news. You know all this slop we are dealing with? The physical analogy of that has been evergreen in contracting and trades.
Your customers won't understand why your work is better than your competitor who charges less and does way worse work that doesn't instantly catch on fire.
Even code enforcement will sign off on things that will make you weep.
The lack of respect for a job well done predates AI, and is not at all limited to it.
I don’t know how you were raised but being an electrician is hard physical work. It’s very blue collar. Are you able to give up your office worker status and still feel satisfied? I wouldn’t. Being a blue collar worker changes your status in society and how people view you whether you want it to be true or not. Obviously, if there’s no other option, it makes sense and you don’t have a choice. As a software engineer, my peer groups and friends are doctors and lawyers, etc. Anecdotally it never includes anyone from the trades, including plumbers electricians roofers, and all of that. No one is consciously excluding these people. It just doesn’t seem to happen as naturally.
At a very baser level being a software engineer makes me feel like an important man in society being an electrician would not give me the same feeling. Obviously this is totally arbitrary, but I think the vast majority of software engineers think this way…
Out of curiousity, what country are you from? I'm a software engineer in Australia and my experience couldn't be further from yours, and your attitude is something I haven't encountered widely IRL so wondering if I'm in a bubble or this is just a cultural difference.
The US
Not a software engineer or father sky, but I would take the status hit of leaving an office job in a heartbeat if something manual paid just as much and as stably (including secondary costs). I would dig holes and clean toilets.
For sure, so would I but I’m just saying it wouldn’t make me feel as satisfied with my life and it’s something to think about when this is going to apply to one of the largest well paid groups in America.
Also depends where you live and your mindset. I'm a SWE and have friends that are doctors, professors, dancers, do desk jobs, construction, store clerks, university researchers, designers, electricians, PMs and other SWE. We are all on same level, socially, with each other. The most recent friend in a group is a construction worker and I could sense some inferiority coming from them in the beginning towards some of us, but now they're way past that, as it should be.
They may be excluding you and your elitist attitude, to be honest, rather than the other way around. I’m a SWE and all my friends are blue collars, probably because I generally don’t vibe at all with the wannabe rich.
I will also mention that SWEs aren’t really socially in the same class as doctors and lawyers, they view us as closer to a trade worker than to an accredited professional, which is pretty much how this profession was before the internet era insanity.
> At a very baser level being a software engineer makes me feel like an important man in society being an electrician would not give me the same feeling.
odd, because i think most would say that the electricians are more important to society than almost all swes. i'd love to become an electrician partly because i would feel much better about my contribution to the world.
> At a very baser level being a software engineer makes me feel like an important man in society being an electrician would not give me the same feeling. Obviously this is totally arbitrary, but I think the vast majority of software engineers think this way…
This is genuinely hilarious. (Got to say I do not disagree, but it's pleasantly blunt and honest).
The long term psychological effects of deploying your work to 10000 servers that then sit there idling all day.
> At a very baser level being a software engineer makes me feel like an important man in society being an electrician would not give me the same feeling. Obviously this is totally arbitrary, but I think the vast majority of software engineers think this way…
A consequence of defining yourself by your career and tech companies blowing smoke up peoples asses for the last 20 years I guess. Most devs are closer to electricians and plumbers than they like to think. The internet is just a series of tubes and you just connecting them together.
True, but you missed the "in society" part.
I didn't.
Outside of perceived earning potential and perhaps other software engineers not too many people are excited or exalt this career and I think that is true about most jobs.
>being an electrician would not give me the same feeling
maybe; but it sure would give me another month I can pay my rent and not sleep in a ditch somewhere
Exactly. And moreover, if you put your mind to it, you can be happy doing anything. As I've grown older, I've realized how flexible life can be if you set aside some free time for yourself just to enjoy friends, a good meal, and some hobbies.
Or do you mean "prestige"? We blind now?
>No one is consciously excluding
I wouldn't be so sure.
There's always the possibility that when the successful honest tradesmen are partying, they don't want to associate with anybody who has any air of snootiness, or something like that.
I might be just being irrationally emotional, but I feel this... sort of "fear of God" (not even RSI or whatever, just, literal God) shaking me down to my very core.
I think what's going on in my own head is that something foundational in my 'stack of beliefs' has been shown to be wrong, even if I don't quite know yet 'which' specific jenga piece got whacked.
But even knowing that this is likely what's going on in my own head doesn't help the feeling of that "fear of God". I... I don't know.
This is interesting. We don’t talk very much about how strange a thing it is to live in the period where we confirm that humans are not the only intelligent, speaking thing in the universe. We kind of figured, but finding +1 ina very different kind of mind means there are probably others.
That should maybe be more devastating to people’s worldviews than it has been. Or maybe it’s being much of the denialism that always pops up in AI threads.
More than fear of God, what's boiling inside of me is anger.
Who the hell decided we were to have a God ruling over us? Not even an infinite benevolent being, but a flawed demiurge. Idiots rushing towards the construction of one, even more idiots praising the new idol.
Personally, a little less excited and feeling a bit left out, a lot of the more interesting stuff is being done with massive investments I could only dream of.
Yeah I feel that.
9-10 years ago I was in a smaller structure and basically doing close to SOTA work in the field of NLP: contributions to `spacy`, some of the best word2vec models models for our language (french) and good english ones, at least models that crushed other word2vec models of the time on our large corporate benchmarks (both french and english), and were on par (english) and sometimes better (french) than the official benchmarks of the time. Mostly through minor model tweaks but major data sanitation and preparation work. And then custom transformer-based architecture for other NLP tasks that were also better than all off-the-shelf NLP solutions of the time. And even on my free time I could do some cool ML/NLP stuff no one else was really doing.
Now I am in a larger structure with more resources, yet I know that both in terms or resources and honestly to a degree in terms of skill I feel left out of the current NLP/AI SOTA landscape.
I have a friend who is a great expert on rule-based machine translation and natural language understanding in the classical sense (intellectually describing, in detail, how individual natural languages work and are structured), and none of her techniques have achieved state-of-the-art results for some years. The famous bitter lesson.
It sounds like you were already doing statistical NLP (the thing that has been clobbering everything rule-based in performance) but have seen that field itself start to require much greater resources than what you were working with.
Were you actively working on the Riemann Hypothesis? What are you being left out on?
I didn't set an AI to work on the Riemann Hypothesis, nor decompiling GTA5 or Zelda, nor anything else of the sort. Because I didn't do that, I am incompetent.
mostly just depression, I feel little hope that this technology will positively impact my life, feel like my job is at risk and fear the consolidation of wealth and power at these freaks at the labs trying to build god and end the world.
I don’t see it mentioned, really at all, and I’m not trying to fed-post, but if I was CEO of an AI company I would be paying for POTUS level security.
If rationalists believe humanity will be destroyed unless certain people are eliminated then won't they...I mean it seems like they would.
Learning and understanding the history of technology and its impact on the human condition will make you feel better.
Lay the simple idea on us please
Ted K would have a different take on that.
AI has dominion over the digital world. Math, Go, Chess. They're all pure reason and verification is as fast as you can compute.
Room temperature superconductors are still a ways off imo.
I think giving them physical bodies is a mistake to rush into. Human bodies are a pretty unique bridge between the physical and digital. A chokepoint we probably shouldn’t rush to widen.
And yet people still play chess and go
I'm guessing less frequently to earn a living off of.
I've been investing for this moment my whole life. I'm trying to meditate more so I'll have something to do with my free time and hopefully be less impacted by the loss in career status.
What happens if job loss happens fast enough to threaten investments?
Then we're all fucked. Not much I can do there.
The is a cartoon take
I know you're grieving the changing world but if you have an actual argument to make you should try making it
I get moments I can only describe as lucidity, or a feeling of hyper-reality. Most of the day I just go with the flow of living, but every so often it’s as if the protective mechanisms in my brain switch off, and I’m hit with a weird mix of feelings that boils down to “holy shit, this is actually happening”. I remember having similar moments as a teenager, when I’d suddenly realize, on a really visceral level, that I am in fact going to die some day, as if my brain would stop hiding the "truth" from me for a brief moment. This feels similar.
I love this description and it resonated with me
I can't stop thinking what happens the moment we get something like Claude working in a general purpose humanoid robot
When all this starts to extend to the physical world
The threshold would be "when does producing a physically humanoid robot get cheaper than hiring a human".
I suspect some of the human labor is so cheap at the moment, and the factory is slow but battle tested (just get two people in a quiet room, wait a few years, and voila) as opposed to all the mining and robotics and energy and maintenance etc... for an army of robots - it may very well still not be financially profitable to have robot buttlers, maid, sweepers, nurses, etc...
I get the self reinforcement thing, but physics have a way of winning in the end...
Built once, all they need is energy. They can work 24/7 365 days of the year.
I do not think humans can compete on price, for one robot will be worth at least three humans in hours worked per day. Question is only if such a robot can be made and how long it lasts until ceasing to function.
Built once, they then need periodic maintenance and replacement like any mechanical device (general-purpose robots will be exposed to real-world stresses and danger, after all), and then there is the question of whether the cost of these services outweighs the cost of human labour. In countries where human labour is extremely cheap, e.g. the Indian Subcontinent and GCC countries, it may take a long time for the cost advantage to decisively shift towards robots.
They will repair themselves.
I was intending to snark something like "With pieces that they build themselves from minerals that they mine themselves in country that they rule themselves ?"
But then, as often in those debates, it's hard to say something ludicrous enough for the answer not be a terrifying : "well, yes ?"
Anyway, I hope all the new anthropic millionaires will enjoy life while it lasts. A couple of them might fund companies that will help us survive a few more years. But surely the IPO was worth it, right ?
Consider that in the US, internal combustion engine personal cars have been thriving industry from the 40s to... arguably today. And yes, they need periodic maintenance, replacement, and some uhh... simplification of the environment, and yet all they do is transport the labor for a few hours a day, sitting idle most of the time.
We just need someone to invest a huge amount of money into it. If they go broke we'll still have the tech.
It feels increasingly hard to plan for the future. There's little choice but to assume the future will be enough like the past to be predictable from my experience and knowledge, but that seems less and less likely.
For now, same old stuff. Go to work, keep up with the latest changes, get the kids to school, plan to send them to college. Hard to say if that's the right move at the moment, but what else is there?
you could make sure to buy land while you can and start your vegetable garden and produce as much food for your consumption as possible.. that's what i did, make me sleep better at night
That's cool for you, but most people on the planet can't do that, and there's nowhere near enough land for everyone to do that on an individual basis.
Your username checks out.
Anyway, I'd wager most people on this forum can do that.
In my opinion it shows how broken our governance / political systems are. The way you feel like this reality imposed on you really is a kind of violence in my opinion.
I basically just try over in the moment if each day and hope we have many left.
It is absolutely violence. Several writers have already noted that, like Mark Boyle and Slavoj Zizek in their books...
The domain of freedom we have is increasingly shrinking so that we can prop up a new system that will make us irrelevant.
I'm a mathematician and I feel neither. I feel apathy.
It's 4CT on speed.
Some context for non-mathematicians (like me): the Four Color Theorem was the first major theorem to be proved with extensive computer assistance, which caused a major kerfluffle when it happened back in the 1970’s.
Exactly! It spurred the discussion of what the purpose of mathematics and proofs are.
Is mathematics simply a list of true statements? Or is there some intrinsically human aspect?
Explainable answers are intrinsically human. You wouldn't have the 4CT issue if you didn't care about humans understanding it.
I'm no expert on the matter, but it does look like the current explanation is that there's a whole ton of cases in 4CT, and they can all be checked off individually, but it's inelegant.
So back to the point there, we might be on the verge of getting a whole pile of theorems that you can check every piece of, but without a map that humans can read.
It's so that we could build cool tangible reliable things in the real world.
There's a lot of math which has almost 0 chance of being applicable to building tangible reliable things in the real world.
Then, it would offer a glimmer of hope: mathematicians have not disappear after 4CT, maybe they can survive this ?
Well, yes and no. Essentially all research on 4CT was killed with Appel & Haken, with no new understanding gained.
Ok, they all moved to something else, then ?
I suppose the question is "will we run out of oil and gas and minerals to power the AI" before we "run out of interesting mathematical problems"...
I was around in the 1970s, and although I'm not a mathematician (by a long shot!) I went talks given then by mathematicians about the 4CT proof. I don't remember any of them expressing the kind of existential crisis and sense of doom that you are hearing from some mathematicians today. Back then the debate seemed to be limited to "Should we consider this to be a proof at all?".
Yeah, figure turns to ground pretty quickly. But, apathy is poison when attention is all you need.
>Is anyone else struggling with feelings of both excitement and terror?
Yes, I live with 2 women.
Excitement only.
What a time to be alive!
I just bought homesteading land in New Mexico. It's just terror for me.
Nope, I feel unfazed. To quote The Dude:
"I can't be worried about that shit. Life goes on, man."
I am here for you, email in my profile.
Just calm down. We can talk about it, I am willing to listen to you.
Are there any loved ones near you or someone you would consider a close friend?
Where are you located? I might be able to send help right away.
Edit: Damn! He/she/they has/have not replied. I hope it's not too late now.
I have a theory that it much better to be a business owner right now than it is to be an employee.
Employees are currently getting either the same deal as they always got, or a much worse deal (dropping pay, layoffs, loss of job satisfaction). Whereas the benefits of AI mostly all go to the owner of the business (if they can indeed realise substantially increased productivity).
Sure you could be someone who loves working with AI, or a business owner who is struggling to capitalise on the AI productivity benefits. But broadly speaking, I see very few benefits of this change heading to employees, and a whole lot of potential for business owners.
Put your savings into ANT.
Dumb question but with something like 15 million lines of Lean code, how can we tell when the Lean build “passes” that it is actually formally verifying the right thing and there wasn’t just a “1+1=2” making it pass? Like you hear people say “if your Rust program compiles then it’s correct” but that never meant your business logic is correct. I’m not suggesting malfeasance or intentional error, just that maybe the model spit out something that “passes” but doesn’t actually prove what it says it does.
https://xenaproject.wordpress.com/2026/11/12/and-the-proof-i... addresses this question
> if your Rust program compiles then it’s correct” but that never meant your business logic is correct.
These are two completely different things. Lean doesn't check the "business logic." It checks "types."
In layman's terms:
a.foo();
If this compiles, you know that `a` has a type on which `foo()` is callable (type). You don't know what `foo()` does or what it's supposed to do (business logic).
You're misunderstanding the analogy.
When writing programs that do things to a spec, it would be a fallacy to suggest that just because the program compiles, it implements the spec. Maybe it's a sound implementation of a different spec.
This is directly analogous to formalizing mathematics - it is totally legitimate to want to verify that the statement actually proven is genuinely the Riemann Hypothesis as expressed in natural language.
As it happens, the statement of RH was already formalized and checked by humans to be faithful (but not proven...) in mathlib, which is why the proof was believed so widely, so quickly.
The lines between the two are blurred in type theory (which Lean is based upon) where you can express your business logic in the types. Look up “propositions as types”.
Thus the type checker actually does verify the logic of it all.
> Thus the type checker actually does verify the logic of it all.
It's still possible for it to not prove what you thought it was proving, eg. differences between the human natural language proof and the Lean proof.
I understand that Tao does not want to promote a result which could turn out to be incorrect, but I simply cannot imagine posting about a Riemann Hypothesis result and not commenting about the significance.
I would think that readers of his blog are already familiar with its significance.
The comments on the blog supply a measure of discussion of the significance, even if Terry is withholding comment for the moment.
What actually IS the significance of a proof? People on Reddit say "not much value in proof because operative assumption was it is true, so nothing changes". I know nothing about it.
I would offer an alternative that I haven't heard yet.
The standard answer was that if somebody could prove it the techniques itself would require and add new insight.
However, that does not seem to be the case for now, as its currently several GB.
Instead, what I find significant, is that a lot of people were presuming Elegant math and what we got is several GB - and it might just be that.
There is an obvious tectonic shift happening but seeing RH proven like this and perhaps _not_ be reducible to something understandable by a human would be the nail in the coffin for what I believed math and logic is, and a starting shot for something new entirely.
I'm not too plugged into the academic world - so maybe they've already understood this.
3b1b had hopes that maths in the age of AI would become about explaining and simplification. However, I now have to entertain the idea if not outright accept the reality, that the biggest questions we thought to ask have answers that simply sit outside the realm of human capability to wrap our head around.
The significance for me is we lose the presumption of elegance.
Instead our human-maths are the tip of the iceberg that just so happen to be simple enough to be human comprehensible; and a sampling error on our part to think the pattern would hold.
Even in principle I’d reject this idea. Humans already break large pieces of math up into pieces (see the complete classification of finite simple groups and basically any other large work with multiple authors), so in a sense we’ve already been in this regime where things are too big to wrap our heads around for a long time. It’s not that tectonic of a shift. If anything it’s kind of an insult because the relationship implied here is that mathematicians should spend their time trudging through 200,000 page proofs instead of collaborating with other humans, which is a complete waste unless we know the AI can output the most succinct and powerful version of the proof (which we’re pretty sure it can’t, see the other comment about another GRH manuscript - at 1000 pages it’s still long, but makes the LLM one look suspiciously like LLM slop)
I wouldn't be too sure; there was another post a couple minutes ago from the?chair? of the American Mathematical Society where they were in a rush to post a proof of the GRH that someone has been working for years and is 'only' 900 pages compared to the hundreds of thousands for the Anthropic one.
Yes, this is correct. Every working number theorist assumes it is true. So this validates those assumptions and many theorems whose hypothesis is "if RH then X" will now be shortened to "X is true"
Yes, but sometimes it seems like almost everything "interesting" is contingent upon RH. So this proof proving valid would be like pouring concrete where there used to be a toothpick sculpture.
To be fair, the proof of the quasi-RH was reinforcing the toothpick sculpture with some epoxy.
Of any proof? Of this proof?
The impact of the RH proof (assuming nothing torpedoes it) is any of the new machinery involved in the proof.
Agree, I know I don't fully grasp how big a moment this could be....but If its actually solved I know it would be massive.
That said Just because something is solved doesn't mean we don't work on making the proof simplified and easier to understand.
Maybe he understands that a proof that no one understands is not really useful, so the significance is fairly lessened until the result is boiled down and understood.
>Maybe he understands that a proof that no one understands is not really useful
Compared to the volumes of pure math proofs which are useful?
>so the significance is fairly lessened until the result is boiled down and understood
Significant enough to make a blog post about it the same day it occurs, but not significant enough to mention the significance of it within the blog post itself lol
I imagine Tao is just being careful and conservative with what he's saying it this point. His previous posts discussing AI in mathematics probably garnered way more attention (including negative attention) than he expected, so it'd be fair if he kept his perspective a bit more neutral and muted now. But it's pretty obtuse to assume that Tao doesn't consider this to be one of the most important events in his life. You don't need a PhD in mathematics to appreciate the significance of this.
The Pope is forwarding reports that the sixth seal has broken, but not elucidating the significance.
As some others in the thread, I truly find this moment scary. I feel that right now AI essentially completely surpassed human intelligence. For now the results from AI are limited by what's easy to do within the computer "with pen and paper", but surely it's matter of time before this is unleashed in other fields. For a scientist this is scary, because it is unclear if there is space for research by people anymore. But I start to worry about actual dangers from this intelligence and where it can lead.
I feel like people under discuss how important RLVR is to the mathematical results. I'm not entirely convinced that AI as it currently stands will perform as well in fields where you can't perform verification instantly. After all, the idea that you could mechanically derive all of mathematics from a concise set of axioms is a very old one -- it's not surprising that a computational system would be able to derive all of mathematics, barring all what's disallowed by Godel, from first principles. I'm not sure how well this would translate to biology when we have no idea what the axioms might even look like. My god, I read a recent paper asking whether zebrafish even have astrocytes (they do).
I think what humans are better at than AI, is an ability to learn on the spot, which might be what allows us to discover new things. If it takes AI thousands more tokens to learn a particular theory (even a very verifiable mathematical one), it will be limited to knowledge generated by others, while a human can generate the training knowledge right in their head, since it takes so little of it to absorb it for new concepts. Even though RLVR exists, which allows for generation of infinite verifiable problems, it is limited by what humans at the AI company can think up. Though AI will probably start learning efficiently too after some time.
I think math is special though. Math is great for AI because it lives entirely in the abstract space. AI's weakness still is, its lack of integration with the real world and real world data. With math, AI doesn't have to 'guess' anything, of what a thing actually is from text data. With math, the map is the ground.
There are increasingly few intuitive maths left to discover, I think, where a human's accumulated 'world model' transfers. I feel those have mostly been discovered. But in other fields, taste still plays a part, taste that is aquired from interacting with the real world, and also from the very different process of learning things laboriously; one at a time. And who knows, maybe in math as well there are still a lot to be offered by the human approach.
I think this is a very special reverse-honeymoon phase where we feel like AI is robbing our lunch money, because we have been laboring on some things that, as it turned out, AI is much better at. Once we've mapped those out, get a feel for which problems AI would be better at, we won't spend more time on those any longer, but I think those wouldn't be the whole pie of intellectual activities. Or of researches. At least I hope.
Could someone explain the difference (if any) between the Generalized Riemann Hypothesis and what has historically been called the Riemann Hypothesis?
The Riemann hypothesis is a statement about the nontrivial complex-valued zeroes of the Riemann zeta function given by zeta(s) := sum to infinity of 1/n^s, namely that such zeroes all have real part 1/2. It has been extended and specialized many ways since being posed by Riemann over 150 years ago, but perhaps the most important is the generalized Riemann hypothesis which replaces the Riemann zeta function with the Dirichlet L-function. In other words GRH says: All nontrivial zeroes of the Dirichlet L-function L(chi, s) = sum to infinity of chi(n)/n^s, for primitive Dirichlet character chi, have real part 1/2.
It's interesting to me that the ANT GRH proof appears to have been generated directly in Lean, whereas the OAI NS proof I believe was produced in natural language then formalized into Lean.
Maybe GRH was as well, I haven't seen much about how these were put together. But, it's a curious difference in approach if not.
Future of mathematics has two frontiers - one that LLMs can derive and another that we can understand. When the science studied is completely abject, what is the point of an LLM doing it.
I haven't been so excited about math in a long time.
True. I had a similar feeling when OpenAI showcased their Dota2 bots, when DeepMind showcased AlphaGo, or whenever I play chess and can check the engine's analysis. Exciting times, with much to learn.
But what is the Riemann zeta function? Visualizing analytic continuation (3blue1brown): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sD0NjbwqlYw
The pattern seems to be that AI is capable of some amazing things, when assisted by Levent Alpöge.
Slow day. Unforced NS, GRH and an reverse engineered cat litterbox.
Interesting times. AI math will be applied by engineers, and mathematicians themselves will become mere astronomers or archaeologists of the universe of mathematical knowledge, the grid of which AI has already constructed.
If llms can solve these open problems in math, the biggest question is what is going to happen with cryptography. So far cryptographically related math problems are suspiciously absent from all the new math development.
But I think there's a very good chance cryptographically relevant developments are just around the corner. There's a good chance that's why both anthropic and open ai have not released their latest models.
If public key cryptography were to fall to ai, the social implications could be immense, the whole digital world including cryptocurrency but also software updates (which are the only thing holding cyber security right now with all the ai generated vulnerabilities), credit cards, digital bank access, internet access being secure, public wifis, online markets, work from home, and quite ironically llm access itself will be severely damaged without encryption to protect the session.
I fear that cryptography breaking and all digital systems falling apart might be insignificant to what is coming.
I wish AI would solve and verify P = NP (instead of the ≠ case humans expect.)
that would be a tremendous achievement and contribution to humankind.
With no real commentary from Tao, why is this post notable?
Overwhelmed with GRH today.
It’s worth noting that this is a post from Terry himself rather than him reposting something from somebody else.
I find that a lot of the times that people see the post from Terrys site they attribute the authorship to him when he does a significant amount of reposting.
Usually invited/guest posts rather than reposts (which I usually take to mean linking to a post originally published elsewhere).
So, 2050 huh?